Tag Archives: Mad Men

Why Are the Commercials On Mad Men So Irritating?

Image

There are two major complaints cropping up about this season of Mad Men: the characters are too unlikeable and the commercial breaks are too abrupt. I’m waiting to see how the season plays out to say much about the first complaint (although I will note that I’ve found Don Draper pretty irredeemable for two or three seasons now, but my fascination has never wavered) but the second is in some ways more interesting. The abruptness of the cuts to commercial break on Mad Men is nothing new, but as more television critics stopped getting pre-air screeners from AMC and were forced to watch the episodes live, the complaints have become more and more vocal. However, there’s a possibility that I think is worth exploring: the commercial breaks are supposed to be jarring.

A couple of quick notes. First of all, it is important to establish that the jarring commercial breaks are a matter of authorial intent and not AMC’s fault. Mad Men is a hypnotic, languorous show, more so than almost anything else on TV, and snapping out of its trance is not easy. But, more to the point, there’s a specific structural quirk at play. For those who might not know, most commercial television scripts are structured to accommodate commercials by breaking them up into several acts. Each act corresponds to a segment and ends with an act break, some kind of moment that’s meant to push viewers into the commercial while making sure they’ll want to stick around to see what happens next. Matt Weiner and his writing staff intentionally write episodes of Mad Men without act breaks. They aren’t the only people who do this, but pretty much everyone else who does writes for premium channels like HBO, which are commercial free. This is how Weiner would have written scripts for The Sopranos and how screenwriters have been doing it for decades.

The writers aren’t stupid; they know they’re writing a show with commercials and could choose to accommodate the ads if they wanted. So why don’t they? It could be because this is simply how Weiner wrote on The Sopranos. But he’s not the only writer of the show and The Sopranos isn’t the only show he wrote for (he was also on the staff of Andy Richter Controls the Universe, which aired on FOX). It also could be so the show plays better on DVD and Netflix. But whatever the reason, the result is that it strengthens the show’s critique of American capitalism and, especially, the ways that advertising propagate ideology.

If you are already on-board with the concept that at least part of what Mad Men is doing is critiquing of American capitalism in general and advertising’s role within that system specifically, feel free to move along to the next paragraph, but I would like to show my work a little. Mad Men does more than just peel back the curtain on the process and people behind advertising; it looks like an advertisement. The gorgeous, meticulously arranged mise-en-scene wouldn’t look out of place in a Sterling-Cooper design, but an ad by the agency (or anyone else) would be using those images to suggest that the same perfection and happiness is within your reach through consumption of a given product. On Mad Men, the point is the opposite. These are the people living in those ads, consuming and consuming, and all they’re left with is emptiness and displeasure. Think of “The Wheel,” where Don turns family photos into a literal advertisement for Kodak, convinces himself that domestic perfection is within reach, and then returns to find an empty house.

So Mad Men is a show critiquing advertising’s role in society, but this is a difficult argument to coherently communicate when you have to stop the show down every ten minutes to air commercials. I would argue this is one of the reasons why scholars have been so quick to look down on TV for so much of its history: how incisive and critical can a series be when its main reason for existing is to provide a hospitable atmosphere for advertising. Mad Men side-steps this by creating as inhospitable an atmosphere as possible. The cuts are abrupt and jarring, the show makes no effort to incorporate breaks into its overall structure. The ads don’t fit because the show doesn’t think they should fit.

As a result, the commercials exist as the breaking of a trance, an imperfect, loud, and classless intrusion on the perfect structure of the show. They don’t fit and, as a result, draw attention to themselves. You think critically about them. You notice how irritating and fake they are. You are angry about their very presence. It is a small leap to move from feeling like the presence of the ads is artificial to feeling like the substance of the ads is artificial. Mad Men takes a simple fact of its form, commercial breaks, and contorts them until they fit its larger critique of American society.

Of course, the obvious retort to all of this is the fact that Mad Men has relied on product integration for much of its run. However, as the show has had more autonomy, it has reduced the amount of paid product placement and also made the real brands that appear in the show pay a steep price for that exposure. Most obviously, Jaguar, which was shown as structurally corrupt in “The Other Woman” and utterly unreliable in “Commissions and Fees.” Heinz is shown as immature and high schoolish, with an executive who is a unpleasant, petty mess and the Chevy car that Don and Teddy pitched for last night turns out to be a historic lemon. Those appearances may not have been paid for, but one that was, by Heineken, was used as a backdrop to Don’s humiliating manipulation of Betty.

If I had to guess, I would say the main reason Mad Men ignores the commercial breaks is simply because they can. However, the result is that it deepens one of the show’s most important, and yet easy to miss, themes. These people have been lied to all their lives by the very industry they work for and tricked into believing that the right car and the right suit and the right job and the right wife would make them happy. Why would the show help keep up that illusion when it can subvert it instead?

Leave a Comment

Filed under Uncategorized

Primetime Emmy Nominations: Who Will Win

The September 18 Emmys are still a long time away, but the nominations were announced last night. Here’s our expert analysis on who will win, who should win, and who got snubbed.

BEST DRAMA SERIES

Boardwalk Empire
Dexter
Friday Night Lights
Game of Thrones
The Good Wife
Mad Men

Who Will Win: Mad Men. This is there year to break through the Breaking Bad wall. Boardwalk has a strong chance as well, but I think the boys at SCDP are going to be happy come Emmy night.

Who Should Win: Friday Night Lights. The final season of FNL was not its best (season 1 or 4), but was still very good, and getting a symbolic win in its last season would be great to see. Don’t hold your breath though.

Who Was Snubbed: Justified. Seriously, how was this show forgotten?

BEST COMEDY SERIES
Big Bang Theory
Glee
Modern Family
The Office
30 Rock
Parks and Recreation

Who Will Win: Too Close to Call. This is a really tight category, where any of these shows could take the statue, but…

Who Should Win: Parks and Recreation. Hands down the funniest show with the best cast. The show went nuts this year, with no weak episodes, and if it doesn’t win, I’ll go on a hunger strike (or probably just be mad for a few days).

Who Was Snubbed: Community. The show had a few brilliant episodes this season, including a few that were light on the wacky humor that helped build the shows fanbase, but heavy on tremendously done storytelling. A shame it didn’t get a nod.

BEST DRAMA ACTOR

Timothy Olyphant, Justified
Steve Buscemi, Boardwalk Empire
Kyle Chandler, Friday Night Lights
Michael C. Hall, Dexter
Jon Hamm, Mad Men
Hugh Laurie, House

Who Will Win: Jon Hamm. It’s his year to hold the statue before Cranston comes back. And honestly, if you saw the episode “The Suitcase,” you’ll have no problem agreeing with me.

Who Should Win: Kyle Chandler. Like FNL in the Drama Series category, this would be symbolic, though Chandler was pitch perfect in his final season as Coach Taylor, and deserves it outright.

Who Was Snubbed: This category is surprisingly tight. Not much you can argue here.

BEST DRAMA ACTRESS
Connie Britton, Friday Night Lights
Julianna Margulies, The Good Wife
Kathy Bates, Harry’s Law
Mariska Hargitay, SVU
Mirelle Enos, The Killing
Elisabeth Moss, Mad Men

Who Will Win: Elisabeth Moss. If you saw Hamm in “The Suitcase,” you know Moss deserves an Emmy for her work too. She’s past due, and this will be her year.

Who Should Win: Connie Britton. If I had a vote, I’d vote for Moss, but Britton spent five years doing phenomenal work as Tammy Taylor, and it’s sad to see her come away from it all empty handed.

Who Was Snubbed: January Jones, Mad Men. I’m not the biggest January Jones fan, and Betty didn’t have much to do this season, but when she was on screen, the whole mood of the scene changed. Betty was fascinating to watch this year, thanks in large part to Jones.

BEST COMEDY ACTRESS
Edie Falco, Nurse Jackie
Tina Fey, 30 Rock
Laura Linney, The Big C
Melissa McCarthy, Mike & Molly
Martha Plimpton, Raising Hope
Amy Poehler, Parks & Recreation

Who Will Win: Amy Poehler. Tina Fey might surprise, but I think this is Poehler’s year. She was very good all season, and I think that will be hard to ignore.

Who Should Win: Amy Poehler. Seriously. She was great.

Who Was Snubbed: Alison Brie, Community. Annie is one of the sweeter, more fun characters on TV right now. Just watch her try and be someone else in the bar night episode, you’ll see what I mean.

BEST COMEDY ACTOR
Alec Baldwin, 30 Rock
Matt LeBlanc, Episodes
Jim Parsons, The Big Bang Theory
Steve Carell, The Office
Johnny Galecki, The Big Bang Theory
Louie C.K., Louie

Who Will Win: Steve Carell. He hasn’t won an Emmy yet for playing his most iconic roll, and this is the last chance. Voters won’t forget that.

Who Should Win: Louie C.K. It seems like an odd nomination, but it’s sort of Louie‘s consolation prize.

Who Was Snubbed: Joel McHale, Community. The longer he’s on Community, the better he’s getting.

OUTSTANDING SUPPORTING ACTOR, COMEDY
Chris Colfer, Glee
Jesse Tyler Ferguson, Modern Family
Ed O’Neill, Modern Family
Eric Stonestreet, Modern Family
Ty Burrell, Modern Family
Jon Cryer, Two and a Half Men

Who Will Win: Ty Burrell. It’s gotta be someone from Modern Family, and it might as well be the most consistently funny.

Who Should Win: If not Burrell, Eric Stonestreet. After Phil, Cam is among the funniest characters on TV.

Who Was Snubbed: A long list here, including Danny Pudi, Aziz Ansari, Nick Offerman, Rainn Wilson, all of whom did fantastic work this season on shows that were not Modern Family.

OUTSTANDING SUPPORTING ACTOR, DRAMA
Peter Dinklage, Game of Thrones
Josh Charles, The Good Wife
Alan Cumming, The Good Wife
Walton Goggins, Justified
John Slattery, Mad Men
Andre Braugher, Men of a Certain Age

Who Will Win: John Slattery. Like I said, it’s Mad Men’s year to break through the Breaking Bad wall.

Who Should Win: Walter Goggins or Peter Dinklage. Both were fantastic, but will certainly be forgotten come voting time.

Who Was Snubbed: Not to bring in more Mad Men, but the more the show has gone on the more I like Vincent Kartheiser as Pete, who has yet to get a nomination.

OUTSTANDING SUPPORTING ACTRESS, COMEDY
Jane Lynch, Glee
Betty White, Hot in Cleveland
Julie Bowen, Modern Family
Sofia Vergara, Modern Family
Kristen Wiig, Saturday Night Live
Jane Krakowski, 30 Rock

Who Will Win: Kristen Wiig. This will be her anointment into stardom, much the same way Tina Fey (and hopefully Amy Pohler) got her first Emmy en route to a successful movie career. She deserves it too.

Who Should Win: Julie Bowen. Claire isn’t a likable character without her.

Who Was Snubbed: Rashida Jones, Parks and Recreation. Poor, beautiful Anne.

OUTSTANDING SUPPORTING ACTRESS, DRAMA
Archie Panjabi, The Good Wife
Kelly Macdonald, Boardwalk Empire
Christine Baranski, The Good Wife
Margo Martindale, Justified
Michelle Forbes, The Killing
Christina Hendricks, Mad Men

Who Will Win: Christina Hendricks. This is a really tight category full of deserving actresses, but she’ll have the Mad Men luck behind her.

Who Should Win: Margo Martindale. If you’ve watched Justified, you know why.

Who Was Snubbed: No one here. Fantastic group of actresses.

OUTSTANDING MINISERIES OR MOVIE
Cinema Verite
Downton Abbey
The Kennedys
Mildred Pierce
The Pillars of the Earth
Too Big to Fail

BEST VARIETY SERIES
The Colbert Report
Conan
The Daily Show with Jon Stewart
Late Night with Jimmy Fallon
Real Time with Bill Maher
Saturday Night Live

OUTSTANDING REALITY PROGRAM
Antiques Roadshow
Undercover Boss

OUTSTANDING REALITY COMPETITION
The Amazing Race
American Idol
So You Think You Can Dance
Top Chef

2 Comments

Filed under TV News

Leave Mad Men Alone!

A couple of otherwise excellent previews of the return of Breaking Bad have put me in kind of an awkward position. I’ve been a flag-waver for Breaking Bad since marathoning the entire first season the morning of the second season premiere. It is a great show, probably the best on television right now and certainly the most criminally underwatched. So why do we need to trash Mad Men to make that point? Both New York Magazine’s set profile and Chuck Klosterman’s think piece for Grantland seem to misstate some stuff about Mad Men, all in the process of making a point that I largely agree with.

Broadly, I understand the impulse that is driving all of this. Like when The Wire was being ignored while airing at the same time as The Sopranos, it is insanely frustrating when all your friends watch and obsess over Mad Men but won’t bother with the arguably better show airing on the same network. Mad Men and Breaking Bad become tied together and it becomes more and more irritating that no one seems to care just how GOOD the latter is getting.

But, all due respect, I really don’t understand a lot of the points they’re making. Klosterman says that on Mad Men “every action the characters make is not really a reflection on who they are; they’re mostly a commentary on the era,” which seems kind of asinine to me. Maybe in the first season, when the show a little worse about making “weren’t things different in the 1960s” jokes, that was the case. But what makes Mad Men so effective is just how good it has gotten at digging deep into its characters and having their actions driven by who they are. The ending of this season, where Don Draper chose his sexy but demure secretary over a professional equal, was so frustrating precisely because it was the kind of terrible decision we’ve seen Don Draper make over and over again for the last four years. Klosterman says “all their decision can be excused…by the circumstances of the period…so we can’t really hold [the characters] accountable for what they do” which is the total opposite of what makes Don Draper such a tragic figure. He KNOWS better and still chooses the easy path. The show hardly invites us to excuse his (or any of the characters’) choices and instead invites us to be as angry at them as we want (as in, once again, the completely infuriating season finale).

Meanwhile, the New York Times’ preview of Breaking Bad suggests that Walter White is unique
for the way that he “suffer[s] crushing reversals with lasting impact.” I’m actually not clear on what the writer, David Segal, is trying to say here. Is he saying that, unlike Don Draper, Walt’s misdeeds have left “permanent scars?” Because Don’s lies destroyed his family and seem to have wreaked psychic havoc on his daughter (the extent of which was dramatized this year). And Tony Soprano’s actions certainly had lasting impact on the lives of others around him, even if he never changed. And Breaking Bad’s nearest predecessor, The Shield, was all about the long-term cost of poor choices.

I don’t mean to be the guy scolding other people for comparing two comparable works of art because I certainly do that all of the time. But I guess I feel like Mad Men is being misrepresented? Or at the very least oversimplified in order to prop up the pro-Breaking Bad side? Or maybe I’m just feeling especially good about Mad Men right now for some reason? The important point here is that AMC has two of the greatest shows ever right now and just because we’re excited for one coming back after a far too long hiatus doesn’t mean we need to go around trashing the other one, you know?

Leave a Comment

Filed under Uncategorized

Mad Men Returning in 2012 With or Without Matthew Weiner

Since Mad Men is traditionally a late summer-early fall show, it already feels like forever since its been on. Making matters worse, AMC and show creator Matthew Weiner have been engaged in heated contract talks to keep the show runner attached to the hit series. Today brought both good news and bad news, with AMC announcing it had authorized production on the show, with early 2012 as an air date. The only hitch is that Weiner doesn’t have a deal yet, meaning the show could go on without his guidance. Apparently, AMC is asking for a few things, including reducing two minutes off the show’s run time to run more ads and cutting back on the screentime of some major characters, while Weiner is reportedly asking for somewhere in the range of $30 million, which would make him one of the highest paid showrunners in television. No matter whose side your on, it sounds like a mess that could jeopardize the quality of one of the best shows on television. Stay tuned for more.

Leave a Comment

Filed under TV News

TUiW Best of 2010: The 15 Best TV Episodes of 2010

Presented in no particular order, our 15 favorite episodes of TV from 2010.

Mad Men – The Suitcase
If there was one episode of television that may have won its stars an Emmy, it was “The Suitcase,” a beautifully performed, perfectly written hour of television. Jon Hamm and Elizabeth Moss were extraordinary, their chemistry never better, as Peggy and Don spend a night battling and bonding in the SCDP offices. Mad Men has had several top notch episodes, but few can rival “The Suitcase.” (M)

Community – Modern Warfare
Community had several solid episodes leading up to “Modern Warfare,” but it was there that the show reached the creative peak of its first season. “Modern Warfare” is part parody, but there is also a lot of reverence to the source material thrown in. There are so many hilarious little details and references throughout the episode, which gets better and better with each viewing. (M)
Read Michael’s original review here.

Lone Star – Pilot
The big comment most critics had regarding the pilot for Lone Star was that it was a great idea for a movie, but maybe not a TV show. Given the show’s swift demise, we’ll never know, but the first episode was about as entertaining as any TV show or film you’ll find. Great performances from Jon Voight and newcomer James Wolk drove a compelling, self contained episode that unfortunately will have to stand on its own as a great piece of TV. (M)
Read Michael’s original review here.

Boardwalk Empire – Boardwalk Empire
When you hire Martin Scorsese to direct the first episode of your TV series, this is what you get. The extra-long series premiere of Boardwalk Empire was jam-packed with gangland violence, political intrigue, and fascinating historical tidbits, all administered at such a quick pace that viewers understandably got whiplash once the show settled into a slightly more sedate weekly pace. From the apocalyptic ringing-in of Prohibition to the staccato, rim-shot scored stick-up sequence, “Boardwalk Empire” was a tense, exciting glimpse into a world that I couldn’t wait to spend more time inside. (J)
Read Jonah’s original review here.

The Walking Dead – Days Gone By
One of the most anticipated new shows of the fall, The Walking Dead delivered a chilling, highly entertaining first episode that instantly won it a legion of fans. Functioning just as well as a standalone story as it did a pilot, “Days Gone By” is about as cinematic as you can get on television. If nothing else, “Days Gone By” did a fantastic job of quickly luring in a loyal fanbase that made the show one of basic cable’s biggest. (M)

Party Down – Party Down Company Picnic
“Party Down Company Picnic” takes the show’s cast out of their bowties only to find that there is no escape from the tedious cycle of boredom that is their lives. Henry breaks up with Uda and steps down as Team Leader, Ron’s attempts at climbing the ladder put him right back where he started – occupying the now vacant Team Leader job – and Party Down gets their asses kicked by Valhalla. In an inspired second (and tragically, final) season, few episodes wrung as much laughter out of as much pain as this one did. (J)
Read Michael’s original review here.

30 Rock – Brooklyn Without Limits
People (like myself) who were ready to give up on 30 Rock after a substandard season were jumping the gun, as the show has come roaring back in 2010. Nowhere was the resurgence clearer than “Brooklyn Without Limits,” a piece of vintage 30 Rock mayhem, complete with a guest star (John Slattery) who feels put to use well without dominating the episode. Add to that Lemon’s new jeans and Jenna’s insecurities and “Brooklyn Without Limits” was another worthwhile addition to the series. (J)

Better Off Ted – Lust in Translation
We decided that there weren’t really enough Better Off Ted episodes in 2010 for us to put it on the series list, so this will have to stand as our tribute to one of our favorite fallen shows. “Lust in Translation” featured a premise that was classic Better Off Ted, complete with an angry-voiced multi-translator, a talking frying pan, and a panoply of Three Stooges references. From Phil and Lem’s realization that they are evil scientists to the triumph and heartbreak of Lindabagel, “Lust in Translation” is a reminded of how sharp and funny Better Off Ted could be and how sad it is that its gone. (J)
Read Jonah’s original review here.

Lost – Happily Ever After
The joy of Lost is the joy of discovery and adventure, the feeling that the boundries of the show’s world are limitless and ever-expanding. Every time a new piece of mythology was introduced or a new question asked, viewers’ minds started racing, imagining all the possibilities that existed. It is not shocking that the best episodes of the show, then, are the ones that asked questions, not the ones that answered them. So “Happily Ever After” gets our vote over the still-terrific-no-matter-what-anybody-says finale because it was vintage Lost: Desmond and the audience stranded in a strange world whose very existence was a mystery to us. And by grounding that mystery in the show’s sweetest love story, Lost made “Happily Ever After” as moving as it was intriguing. (J)
Read Jonah’s original review here.

Parks and Recreation – Telethon
“Telethon” worked in everything from a harrowing look into Jerry’s sex life (shudder) to ex Indiana Pacer small forward Detlef Schrempf while maintaining its focus on classic P&R elements like Leslie’s boundless enthusiasm and Ann and Mark’s relationship. The series of callbacks (Pawnee Today, Sweetums, Mouse Rat) and the endless parade of one-liners (“there are two kinds of diabetes but only one kind of caring: type one caring”) make “Telethon” feel like a summation of everything that made season two so special. (J)
Read Michael’s original review here.

The Office – Niagra
Jim and Pam have always been at the emotional center of The Office, so it’s not a huge surprise that their wedding would be the best episode in a season of the show that was less than stellar. It was a sweet, funny episode that was reminiscent of the show’s peak, and helped remind us why we fell in love with The Office in the first place. (M)

Breaking Bad – One Minute
Breaking Bad does tension like no other show currently on TV. So when the twin assassins who seemed to be the season’s main concern turned their attention to DEA agent Hank, all while Hank’s life is collapsing around him. From his violent confrontation with Jesse to his heartbreaking confession to his wife, Hank finds himself coming to the sad realization that he can no longer be a cop anymore, which only makes it that much more tense that two reapers are coming for him. Then a mysterious phone call and a Breaking Bad-style chain of causation turn the tables on the cousins. The fact that, while all this is going on, the show still manages to find time to take Jesse and Walt’s relationship to a new place and work in some vintage Saul Goodman smarm is icing on the cake of what may be the most tense episode of television ever. (J)

How I Met Your Mother – Rabbit or Duck
With a plethora of call backs and references and classic HIMYM troupes throughout, “Rabbit or Duck” was a classic episode of the show that helped salvage a lackluster season. The main story of Robin falling in love with co-worker Don bringing the emotional thread and the b-story of Barney and his always ringing cell phone bringing the laughs, “Rabbit or Duck” is a complete episode, one that can be enjoyed from all angles. (M)
Read Michael’s original review here.

Modern Family – Truth Be Told
Modern Family deserved all the praise it got for its first season, as highlighted by “Truth Be Told,” an episode in which all of the show’s strengths are put on display. There aren’t many weak links, and the physical comedy of Phil evading his ex-girlfriend while Claire remains oblivious was one of the funniest bits the show did. Coming in the second half of the season, “Truth Be Told” solidified Modern Family as the best new comedy of they year. (M)
Read Michael’s original review here.

Justified – Pilot
More pilots should be like Justified’s zippy and thrilling introduction. Of course, most pilots don’t have the benefit of being adapted from Elmore Leonard short stories. Portraying US Marshall Raylan Givens gives Timothy Olyphant a character right in his wheelhouse, an easy-going man of righteousness and violence with a seething anger burning underneath the surface. Raylan returns home and quickly butts heads with Boyd Crowder, an old coal-mining buddy of his played perfectly by Walton Goggins. The pair’s cat-and-mouse game unfolds over the course of the hour and comes to an exciting conclusion that wisely keeps both men around to antagonize each other for the remainder of the season. As an introduction to Justified’s world or just as an hour of TV, “Pilot” works on just about every level. (J)

Leave a Comment

Filed under Best of 2010, TV Review

TUiW Best of 2010: The 10 Best TV Shows of 2010

The TUiW Best of 2010 list bonanza rolls on, now with our list of the 10 Best TV Shows of 2010.

10. Lost
It would have been impossible for Lost to answer every lingering question and appease everyone in its final season, but for those hoping for closure for the characters they had grown to know and love, it was an extremely satisfying season. Yes, it’s easy to go after things like the “Heart of the Island,” but there were so many moments, especially in the FlashSideways, that tugged at the heartstrings. Ultimately, the last season of Lost reminded us that the reason the show succeeded while the knockoffs failed because it had characters we wanted to be happy, and in that regard, the ending was a complete success. (M)

9. Treme
If there’s one thing Treme was not, it’s The Wire 2. Viewers looking for Omar and Hamsterdam and “Where’s Wallace” type scenes were bound for disappointment. Those who stuck around, however, were rewarded with a series of rich, warm character portraits. Featuring one of the best casts on TV (including standouts Melissa Leo, Khandi Alexander, Clarke Peters among others), the show felt more alive and more human than anything else currently airing. Even if some of the plot points didn’t quite gel the way we might have hoped (Sonny), the show itself made for a promising start from one of TV’s brightest visionaries. (J)

8. Louie
It’s hard for comics to successfully move their act to a sitcom setting, but Louis C.K. did it successfully in his brilliant new show. Louie is truly unlike any show on TV, a brutally honest, downright hilarious exploration of everything, whether its politics, homophophia, God, terrorism, and the challenging experience of flying, all with signature point of view of its creator. Serving as writer, director, and editor, Louis C.K. has created a comedy that plays more like a series of short films than it does a typical tv show. (M)

7. Community
Community makes it easy to focus on the gadget episodes and pop culture awareness by being so good at it. Episodes like “Modern Warfare” and “Abed’s Uncontrollable Christmas,” Community has made a name for itself with some of the smartest parody episodes ever on TV. But what makes Community a truly outstanding show is the measure of heart and empathy it displays for each one of it’s off-beat characters. From a smarmy lawyer to a high-strung overachiever, the characters on Community have transcended their simply types and become a rich collection of people. (J)

6. Boardwalk Empire
HBO has always been successful at creating full realized worlds within their shows, but Boardwalk Empire takes that to a whole new level. With stunning sets and visuals and top notch acting, the Prohibition Era drama is the successor to The Sopranos the network has been searching for. Steve Buschemi shines as Nuckie Thompson, owning the role completely, and the supporting cast is absolutely phenomenal all around. The first season of Boardwalk Empire ushered in a new era for cable dramas, one in which no idea is too big to put on the small screen. (M)

5. Terriers
The people who solve crimes on TV don’t look and act like Donal Logue and Michael Raymond-James. They don’t worry about how to make rent or take cases for a bank manager just to try to secure a loan. And their cases don’t involve women who pretend to have affairs at their husband’s insistence or helping wealthy landowners rob themselves. But Terriers wasn’t like other shows. It had a shaggy, easy-going energy that blended perfectly with its noir elements and some of the best performances on TV. Terriers could regularly punch you in the gut in a way no other TV show did and TV is a flatter place without it. (J)

4. Parks and Recreation
After a tepid first season, Parks and Recreation emerged in its second season as one of the best shows on network television. The show finally emerged from the shadow of its older brother, The Office, consistently being the funniest show in NBC’s strong Thrusday night lineup. Parks and Rec learned to play up the strengths of its phenomenal cast, with Amy Pohler leading the way, but with Aziz Ansari, Nic Offerman, Aubrey Plaza, and Chris Pratt adding just as many fantastic moments. With the late additions of Rob Lowe and Adam Scott, Parks and Rec looks like it will continue its greatness when it returns in early 2011. (M)

3. Mad Men
At the end of its third season, Mad Men liberated Don and Betty Draper from their suffocating, destructive marriage, and then spent the fourth season teaching them to beware what they wished for. This season structured itself like a series of interlocking short stories, giving the audience an even more intimate look at the show’s characters than in years’ past. And, in the end, it made all too much sense to see Don fall back into his same pattern, proposing out of nowhere to his pretty secretary while casting aside his intellectual and professional equal Faye. In the end, this season of Mad Men was about what every season of Mad Men is about: the more things change the more they stay the same. (J)

2. Party Down
It’s a shame that the best comedy of 2010 was one of the least watched or heard of shows of the same year, yet it seems fitting for a show about characters seemingly doomed for failure. The show didn’t miss a beat all season, and actually added more depth to their characters by taking them out of the parties they catered in episodes like “Steve Gutenberg’s Birthday” or “Party Down Company Picnic.” Ken Marino was once again the show’s MVP as perpetual loser Ron Donald, but I could go on and on how good the rest of the cast was. If you missed out on Party Down, you’re not the only one, but do yourself a favor and correct that. You won’t be sorry. (M)

1. Breaking Bad
I meant to recap this season of Breaking Bad, but I just couldn’t do it, at least not without watching each episode three or four times. One week, Breaking Bad could deliver episodes loaded with tension to the point of explosion and then follow them with softer hours that put a close-up focus on the people at the show’s core. Breaking Bad doesn’t let its characters out of making difficult decisions, it doesn’t go gentle on the audience, and it doesn’t play by the rules. From the compelling men at its center – Walter White and Jesse Pinkman – the fascinating characters in their orbit and even people at the periphery, Breaking Bad has created and depicted a world that is fully realized and detailed. (J)

Leave a Comment

Filed under Best of 2010

Golden Globe Nominations Announced

It’s that magic time of year again where the Golden Globe nominations come out and get us excited for the Oscar race, and remind us of all that good TV we’ve been watching. The big guns movie wise got a plethora of nods in the categories that mattered, though True Grit was shut out, perhaps because no one has seen it yet, though it hasn’t stopped some other awards. Thanks to the odd Musical or Comedy category at the Globes, we get a nomination for The Tourist, the “thriller” that got nearly universal critical scorn which made nothing at the box office. Boy, the Hollywood Foreign Press Association sure are tastemakers! The TV nominations are also fairly predictable, but the results should be interesting. Ricky Gervais will host the ceremony January 16. The nominations:

Best Picture, Drama
Black Swan
The Fighter
Inception
The King’s Speech
The Social Network

Best Director
Darren Aronofsky, Black Swan
David Fincher, The Social Network
Tom Hooper, The King’s Speech
Christopher Nolan, Inception
David O. Russell, The Fighter

Best Actress, Drama
Halle Berry, Frankie & Alice
Nicole Kidman, Rabbit Hole
Jennifer Lawrence, Winter’s Bone
Natalie Portman, Black Swan
Michelle Williams, Blue Valentine

Best Actor, Drama
Jesse Eisenberg, The Social Network
Colin Firth, The King’s Speech
James Franco, 127 Hours
Ryan Gosling, Blue Valentine
Mark Wahlberg, The Fighter

Best Musical Or Comedy
Alice In Wonderland
Burlesque
The Kids Are All Right
Red
The Tourist

Best Actress, Musical Or Comedy
Annette Bening, The Kids Are All Right
Anne Hathaway, Love & Other Drugs
Angelina Jolie, The Tourist
Julianne Moore, The Kids Are All Right
Emma Stone, Easy A

Best Actor, Musical Or Comedy
Johnny Depp, Alice In Wonderland
Johnny Depp, The Tourist
Paul Giamatti, Barney’s Version
Jake Gyllenhaal, Love & Other Drugs
Kevin Spacey, Casino Jack

Best Supporting Actress
Amy Adams, The Fighter
Helena Bonham Carter, The King’s Speech
Mila Kunis, Black Swan
Melissa Leo, The Fighter
Jacki Weaver, Animal Kingdom

Best Supporting Actor
Christian Bale, The Fighter
Michael Douglas, Wall Street: Money Never Sleeps
Andrew Garfield, The Social Network
Jeremy Renner, The Town
Geoffrey Rush, The King’s Speech

Best Screenplay
Aaron Sorkin, The Social Network
Christopher Nolan, Inception
Lisa Cholodenko and Stuart Blumberg, The Kids Are All Right
David Seidler, The King’s Speech
Danny Boyle and Simon Beaufoy, 127 Hours

Best Original Song
“You Haven’t Seen The Last of Me,” Burlesque
“Bound To You,” Burlesque
“Coming Home”, Country Strong
“I See The Light,” Tangled
“There’s A Place For Us,” Voyage Of The Dawn Treader

Best Animated Film
Tangled
Toy Story 3
How To Train Your Dragon
Despicable Me
The Illusionist

Best Foreign-Language Film
I Am Love
Biutiful
The Concert
The Edge
In A Better World

Best TV Drama
Boardwalk Empire
Dexter
The Good Wife
Mad Men
The Walking Dead

Best Actress, TV Drama
Julianna Margulies, The Good Wife
Piper Perabo, Covert Affairs
Elisabeth Moss, Mad Men
Katey Sagal, Sons Of Anarchy
Kyra Sedgwick, The Closer

Best Actor, TV Drama
Steve Buscemi, Boardwalk Empire
Bryan Cranston, Breaking Bad
Michael C. Hall, Dexter
Jon Hamm, Mad Men
Hugh Laurie, House

Best TV Comedy
30 Rock
The Big Bang Theory
The Big C
Glee
Modern Family
Nurse Jackie

Best Actress, TV Comedy
Toni Collette, The United States Of Tara
Edie Falco, Nurse Jackie
Tina Fey, 30 Rock
Laura Linney, The Big C
Lea Michele, Glee

Best Actor, TV Comedy
Alec Baldwin, 30 Rock
Steve Carell, The Office
Thomas Jane, Hung
Matthew Morrison, Glee
Jim Parsons, The Big Bang Theory

Best Supporting Actress, TV
Hope Davis, The Special Relationship
Jane Lynch, Glee
Kelly Macdonald, Boardwalk Empire
Julia Stiles, Dexter
Sofia Vergara, Modern Family

Best Supporting Actor, TV
Scott Caan, Hawaii 5-0
Chris Colfer, Glee
Chris Noth, The Good Wife
Eric Stonestreet, Modern Family
David Strathairn, Temple Grandin

Best TV Miniseries
Carlos
The Pacific
Temple Grandin
You Don’t Know Jack
Pillars Of The Earth

Leave a Comment

Filed under Movie News, TV News

2010 Emmys Round-Up

Alright TV fans, this was an Emmy’s for the ages! Here’s our rundown of winners, losers, and surprises!

Winners

The biggest winner of the night was ABC’s breakout Modern Family, who won big and easily won the media created battle between it and Glee, pulling in awards for Best Supporting Actor in a Comedy (Eric Stonestreet, well deserved for the episode “Fizbo”), Comedy Writing, and the big one, Best Comedy Series. Glee got a big win though from their most recognizable star, Jane Lynch, who got a long deserved award for Best Supporting Actress in a Comedy. Like Glee or not, Lynch is a terrific comedienne that has worked her way up the ladder the last 10 years, so it was great to see her win. Also pulling out a surprise win was Aaron Paul, who finally got his Best Supporting Actor in a Drama Emmy for Breaking Bad. Neil Patrick Harris also got his Emmy breakthrough, though for for Best Guest Actor in a Comedy for Glee, losing out on Supporting Actor for How I Met Your Mother yet again. The biggest winner on the night though? Host Jimmy Fallon, who was in his element and hopefully won over some of those people who thought he laughed too much on SNL.

Surprises

This year’s Emmy’s had  a few tricks up their sleeves, among them being Edie Falco’s win for Best Actress in a Comedy, beating out several heavy hitters. Falco herself seemed surprised, proclaiming, “I’m not funny!” from the podium. The other big surprise was The Good Wife’s Archie Panjabi’s win for Best Supporting Actress in a drama, upsetting favorites Elizabeth Moss and Christina Hendricks, both from Mad Men. Jim Parson’s of The Big Bang Theory also had a smaller surprise win for Best Actor in a Comedy, beating out Alec Baldwin, Steve Carrell, and Larry David, though Big Bang has had the adoration of viewers and critics to make it less of a left field choice.

Losers

After doing so well in the Golden Globes, Glee lost out, taking home Best Comedy Writing alongside Lynch’s win. Another big show, Breaking Bad, only took home awards in teh acting categories for Aaron Paul and Bryan Cranston, losing to network pal Mad Men in the Best Drama category. Many thought this would be Breaking Bad‘s year, but evidently, they’ll have to wait a little bit longer. The final season of Lost failed to take home any Emmys, though they were up against stiff competition in every category. After getting nominations for Coach and Mrs. Coach, Friday Night Lights was predictably shut out once more from Emmy glory. A couple of comedy surprises led to loses for Amy Pohler in Parks and Recreation‘s sole nomination and Steve Carell, who has yet to win for his iconic role of Michael Scott with just one year left to go.

Leave a Comment

Filed under TV News

Mad Men – “Christmas Comes But Once a Year”

“No one wants to be alone on New Year’s Eve.” The words that have justified many a compromise, bad decision, or act of emotional terrorism. As is customary for an hour of Mad Men, we get to experience all three!

It is Peggy who says that, late in the episode, referring to her not-fiance Mark (played, it has been brought to my attention, by Karl from Lost; on the plus side neither of Peggy’s parents ever presided over a genocide, but I don’t think Alex had any secret progeny).  Underneath the doofus exterior we saw last week lies a free spirit who just wants to get freaky like they do in Sweden. Peggy has held back and let Mark assume it is because she is still a virgin; Mark thinks that she’s simply being old-fashioned.

Peggy would throw the same accusation at Freddy Rumson. Freddy, last seen pissing himself in his S-C office in season two, is back and sober and in the kind of fraternity that comes with steps and sponsors. Freddy comes to SCDP with an account for Pond’s Cold Cream, an account that he has because he is the sponsor for one of the higher-ups at the company. And yet, the danger for Freddy to return to Madison Avenue is underscored when Roger takes the Pond’s guy out to lunch and they end up getting drunk together. Everywhere around him people are offering him drinks, so it is no surprise when Freddy begs out of the Christmas party.

Neither Freddy nor Mark really gets it. Freddy’s concept for a Pond’s campaign is so bad Peggy thinks/hopes he is joking, while Mark doesn’t understand that Peggy is actually probably far more sexually experienced than him. In the past, we’d have seen Peggy step aside and be who the men need her to be, but she’s grown so much in the past year that she doesn’t want or need to do that anymore. Her dealing with Freddy is a little brutal but the truth is that Freddy’s work doesn’t fit with the company that kicked out the Jantzen people last week. Still, Peggy must have felt bad about it since she acquiesces to Mark.

In case last week didn’t give you a clear picture of how bad things are for Don, we got to see a lot more. Given what an aura he had at SC, it was jarring to hear Joey – the young art guy and John to Peggy’s Marsha – describe him as pathetic. And yet, you can’t really disagree. Don stumbles back to his apartment totally drunk (twice!), makes desperate and pathetic passes at his cute neighbor (played by Nora Zehetner; between her appearance here, Rian Johnson directing the “Fly” episode of Breaking Bad, and Joseph Gordon-Levitt’s supporting turn in a low-budget indie film it has been a good summer for Brick alumni) and the woman there to sell SCDP on a more scientific method of market research. Don predictably walks out of the latter’s presentation, but is it because of a Rumsonesque old-fashionedness? Don ignores the infancy of techniques that we’d see today being used to target ads at more specific audiences; like it or not, this is the direction his field is moving in (of course, the man from the research firm is not too forward-thinking either; Cooper and him share a moment of fear over whether the Civil Rights Act and MediCare are the first steps towards socialism) (it is a good thing we’ve come far enough that today, no one would express similar concerns over a government’s attempt to expand health care services to the needy).

Don comes off as far too desperate (obviously with the nurse, but also in his aggressive flirting with the woman from the research firm who would have been more interested if he had stuck around for the whole presentation) but, in the episode’s darkest moment (both literally and figuratively) he makes a drunkenly makes a move on Allison, his loyal secretary who has just come by to bring him his keys. Allison has been Don’s secretary for a while and she’s easily been his best one yet. Don once again makes an overly aggressive move and, despite seeming hesitant, Allison ends up sleeping with him. Despite the fact that Don is no longer married, no longer has any secrets to keep, he acts incredibly coldly to her the next day. He calls her into his office, doesn’t even explicitly mention what happened, obliquely suggests that it was a one-time deal, and then gives her 2 $50 bills. This is probably the cruelest thing we’ve seen our hero do since his dismissal of Sal; taking a woman with whom he shared an intimate moment and turning her into a prostitute. Not to get too armchair psychologist but with Don’s marriage imploded he seems to be attempting to assert his power and authority over women. He could take the time to treat them like human beings, woo and court them, and eventually sleep with them, but he’d rather treat them like a commodity to be bought and sold.

Or maybe I’m just stretching so that I can compare Allison with Roger “This Job Would Be Great If It Weren’t For the Clients” Sterling, who also finds himself the victim of a power trip by an unpleasant person. Lucky Strike accounts for 69% of SCDP’s income and the rather odious Lee Garner Jr. knows what that means. So his desire to crash the SCDP Christmas party causes Roger to get Joan to turn it from a modest no guests and Velveeta get together to a Caligula-style celebration of decadence. Garner humiliates and controls Roger because he can, because Roger needs his money. He makes Roger dress as Santa, hits on his young wife in front of him, and generally humiliates him. Roger’s never had to work very hard, and it is clear that he doesn’t enjoy being Lee Garner’s manservant. Factor in what Don knows about Garner and this could all end very badly. For now, however, Roger plays the prostitute, catering to Lee Garner Jr.’s whims and power trips for the check.

Finally, creepy Glen is back and has switched Drapers; he sets about impressing Sally with a couple of phone calls soaked in a cloak-and-dagger intrigue that would probably just come off as precocious were it another young child. But it is Glen so instead it just seems like another chapter in a story that ends in him moving to Miami and working as a blood splatter analyst for Metro PD. Anyway, Glen and Sally seem to connect and Sally tells him that she wants to leave the house so Glen (with a sidekick) trashes the Francis house, except for Sally’s room. “Is it a bear?” No Bobby, it is just your creepy neighbor looking for more locks of Draper hair.

Jonah’s Score: 78

TUIW Grade: B+

Leave a Comment

Filed under TV Review

Mad Men – “Public Relations”

Mad Men starts its seasons with a slow, in-medias-res fade up. There’s usually no instigating incident to kick start the action nor is there some kind of introductory scene to summarize what the year will be about. Instead the first hour is about catching up on where these people have been over the last (in this case) 11 months and seeing what’s changed.

We start with someone asking “who is Don Draper” because it is Mad Men and of course that’s how the season starts. The man doing the asking is a reporter with Ad Age who can’t pry much out of the reserved Don. The idea of taking credit for the agency’s innovative Glo-Coat campaign offends Don’s humble and introverted sensibility, but being interviewed at all is dangerous for some with a secret like Don has (something further emphasized by the fact that the reporter lost his leg in Korea – the place where Dick Whitman became Don Draper).

But Don is not in the same position he used to be in. As the driving force behind Sterling Cooper Draper Price, he can no longer afford to be the genius in creative who lets everyone else worry about the business side nor can he be the mysterious cipher who is content to toil away in the background like he could at Sterling Cooper. He is not unlike the Jantzen executives who attempt to have it both ways by caving to the marketplace and selling a “two-piece bathing suit” but refuse to call it a bikini or agree to an advertising campaign that will sell it. Don wants to build a successful and innovative company but, at first, is unwilling to do what he must do in order to make that happen.

Working in closer quarters, for a more freewheeling, seat-of-your-pants kind of agency seems to generally be pretty good for everyone. Roger is back to his wise-cracking and energetic self (he also gets the line of the night, commenting that Ad Age couldn’t even afford to send a whole reporter) and Bert seems back to his old self, but what is really interesting is to see how Pete, Peggy, and Joan all appear to be thriving with their newfound responsibility. Pete brings in accounts, has no problems collaborating with Peggy and seems shockingly comfortable going to power lunches with Roger and Don. Joan finally has an office and the credit that she deserves for doing all the things she was doing at SC.

But its Peggy who seems to have changed the most over the past 11 months. She has a new haircut and good rapport with newbie Joey (incidentally the two of them are paying homage to Stan Freberg’s “John and Marsha;” Freberg himself was an innovative ad man). The close quarters of SCDP mean that there’s no time for the roundabout zigzagging that usually kept Peggy’s voice from being heard. She has the confidence to try a scheme like the ham stunt and the confidence to take Don’s inevitable abuse much better than in the past (she’s even comfortable enough to directly say to him what Roger, Bert, and Lane all tried to say and couldn’t get across).

Betty, meanwhile, provides a top-notch clip for her Bad Parent Hall of Fame highlight reel. At the Francis family dinner she childishly responds to Sally’s refusal to eat anything by stuffing a forkful of sweet potatoes in her face. It seems that the divorce and her new relationship with Henry have simply brought out Betty’s cruelty and selfishness even more. She treats Sally like more like they’re sisters than mother-daughter (and sometimes like Betty is the younger sister), basically ignores Bobby, and keeps the baby away from Don either as some kind of power trip or because it legitimately did not occur to her that Don might want to see him.

It must be hard rushing into a new relationship the way Betty and Henry have (with the added pressure of the divorce and the fact that there are already three children who need care and attention), but, even this early, it is clear the cracks are forming. Henry’s mother has no problems saying horrible thing about her new daughter-in-law and Henry seems to have started internalizing that. He spends most of the episode trying to hook up with Betty, like he’s trying to remind himself of what enchanted him about her to begin with. And whatever Betty thought would be different with Henry doesn’t seem to have quite materialized for her yet.

Don’s zinger to Henry (“believe me, everyone thinks this is temporary”) probably hit a little too close to home, but Don’s personal life isn’t in much better shape. His apartment is impersonal and a little old-fashioned, especially compared to the vibrant office he now works in. Mad Men is all about subverting expectations, but it didn’t take a great mind to predict that Don Draper: Single Man might not be the 1960s Entourage that some viewers wanted it to be. In an interview, Matt Weiner pointed out that, now that he’s once-again available, women would enter relationships with him with a different set of expectations. When he was married, there was clearly no future and therefore no need for extended courting; but now that Don is a bachelor the rules are different. In order to get what he wants – guilt-filled S&M sex without consequences – he will have to literally pay for it (getting slapped repeatedly by a hooker and then paying Peggy $300 for bail: most depressing Thanksgiving ever?).

Bethany seemed to really enjoy their date and sees Don as someone she could potentially keep seeing, but Don is not interested in all of that. Why doesn’t Don hook up with her? It seems like Don’s old tricks may not work on the slightly more liberated women of 1964, or at least in a context where he needs to make a real connection with another human. It is not unlike the newspaper situation (or the bikini situation): Don wants sex but he is unwilling to surrender his mysterious distance and actually open himself up to other people. Conditions have changed and Don is going to have to reconfigure his values if he wants to thrive.

So, in the end, he puts on a big public show of throwing out the Jantzen people after giving them a pitch that is very obviously not what they asked for. Don can’t afford to be the people making bikinis and refusing to do what it takes to sell them. So he schedules another interview and gives that reporter a carefully crafted, slightly embellished narrative: that of the creative genius who escaped his stifling Madison Avenue cage and struck out on his own. It’s a subtler version of the speech he gave to Peggy in “Shut the Door, Have a Seat” – something changed and the old ways of doing things aren’t satisfying anymore.

In many ways “Public Relations” is season three condensed down to an hour. Don realizes that he will need to be more open and different if he wants to build something. “Public Relations” ends with the hopeful promise of Don constructing a more successful and satisfying professional life – but he’s still a long ways away from restructuring the charred wreckage of his personal life. The same for Betty, whose trade of Don for Henry doesn’t seem to have made her any happier or satisfied. But pour one out for Sally Draper, not even a half-hearted present from her new grandmother can make up for a family holiday that is somehow even emptier and sadder than previous ones. Self-loathing, lying, alienation, and delusion: Mad Men’s back everyone!

Jonah’s Score: 75
TUIW Grade: B+

Leave a Comment

Filed under TV Review